Project Type: UMaine

Early life exposure to broccoli sprouts confers stronger protection against enterocolitis development in an immunological mouse model of inflammatory bowel disease. 

This paper is part of a larger Broccoli project, in which we are evaluating the use of broccoli sprouts in the diet to enlist gut microbes to produce anti-inflammatories as a way to resolve symptoms of Inflammatory Bowel Disease.

The Premise

Broccoli sprouts are very high in a compound called glucoraphanin, which is in-active for humans. When glucoraphanin comes in contact with the myrosinase enzyme, also found in the sprouts, it is transformed into sulforaphane, which drives away insect pests but acts as an anti-inflammatory in people!

If you eat raw sprouts, most of this conversion happens when you cut or chew the sprouts, and that anti-inflammatory will get absorbed in your stomach. If you steam or cook the sprouts, you can inactivate the enzyme and leave the glucoraphanin compound alone. Some of your gut microbes are able to use glucoraphanin, and produce the anti-inflammatory sulforaphane right in your gut! We are trying to understand how and when this works, so we can use it to reduce symptoms of Inflammatory Bowel Disease.

A diagram with two panels, and a cartoon mouse in the middle. The cartoon mouse is eating broccoli, and a cartoon of the digestive tract is overlaid on the mouse's abdomen. Lines emanating from the broccoli point to the left panel, and show the compound glucoraphanin being converted into sulforaphane by the myrosinase enzyme. Lines emanating from the colon of the mouse point to the panel on the right, showing the same biochemical conversion by gut microbes.
A cartoon of a woman eating broccoli, with the digestive tract shown on her shirt, and smiling microbes in the background.

The mice in this trial are used to mimic Crohn’s Disease, which is one of the main ways that Inflammatory Bowel Diseases may be classified. Crohn’s Disease is complictaed, and involves an over-active immune response to gut microbes. This is replicated in mice that are bred to lack the genes in the DNA to make interleukin-10 (IL-10). IL-10 is an immune factor that can be used to calm the immune system and tolerate microbes which are not causing harm. Without IL-10, these mice over-react to the presence of bacteria, even those which are not causing harm, and this creates symptoms similar to Crohn’s in people.

We used two age groups of mice, and in each group, half ate a mouse chow (control) diet and half ate the mouse chow with 10% of the chow replaced by raw broccoli sprouts. Crohn’s often develops in childhood and adolescence, so our two age groups of mice reflect the juvenile stage (4-5 weeks old) and the adolescence stage (5-6 weeks old) of symptom onset. After wo weeks of symptoms, we sacrificed the mice and collected as much information as we could.

Figure 1 from the paper mentioned in this post. It shows an experimental design.

The Team

The mice, their care during the experiment, and sample collection for this project was graciously provided by University of Vermont researchers Gary Mawe and Brigitte Lavoie, and then-grad-student-now-medical-student Molly Hurd, in 2021. The SUNY Bingamton team, Tao Zhang and Allesandra Stratigakis, processed metabolite and cytokine samples and analyzed those data. The UMaine team (pictured below and led by Sue Ishaq and Yanyan Li) processed and analyzed data from different locations of gut tissue for histolgy and sequencing of bacterial communities, as well as analyzing those data, and took the lead on writing the paper.

Portrait of Lola Holcomb, wearing a block sweater on a beach at sunset
Lola standing in front of her poster which displays the results of her research on gut microbes.
Louisa Colucci. Young woman with dark hair tied in a bun is sitting in a kayak with her paddle raised. She is wearing a black top and a red life-vest over it, in a light blue, single-person kayak. The kayak is in the water, most likely a lake, with the forested shoreline in the background.

The Health Benefits were most obvious in the younger mice

The mice that were eating the broccoli sprouts in their chow and did much better than the control group who ate only mouse chow when symptoms of Crohn’s Disease were induced — and we found something really interesting… The diet worked really well in the younger mice and reduced their symtpoms of inflammation and illness for almost every metric we studied. The older, adolecent mice got some benefit from eating the raw broccoli sprouts, but not nearly as much as the younger mice! Those graphs are shown in the paper.

The Gut Microbes were most changed in the younger mice

Bacterial richness (the number of different types of bacteria present) was increased, but only in younger mice consuming a 10% raw sprout diet, which is useful because pediatric Crohn’s patients usually have fewer types of bacteria present in their gut.

Younger mice consuming broccoli sprouts also had more types of bacteria that are known to convert glucoraphanin into sulforophane, and they had more of the genes needed to do it. Crohn’s patients usually have fewer of these types of bacteria, which are also known to provide other health benefits.

The Next Steps

We are currently working on replicating and expanding this project to include more age groups, so we can understand how different diet preparations of broccoli sprouts impact immune systems and gut microbiota at different developmental periods of life. We are also really interested in understanding how sex in mice, and gender in humans, plays a role in how immune systems and microbial communities develop during a critical phase of life. We have some initial data to suggest that male and female mice respond to different diets and at differnt ages, but we aren’t sure why yet.

We hope to expand our work with people to study how these diets work in the real world, and how we can tailor diet and cooking preparations of sprouts to best meet the needs of people of different ages, health statuses, and tastes.

The paper

Early life exposure to broccoli sprouts confers stronger protection against enterocolitis development in an immunological mouse model of inflammatory bowel disease. 

Lola Holcomb1$, Johanna M. Holman2$, Molly Hurd3, Brigitte Lavoie3, Louisa Colucci4, Benjamin Hunt5, Timothy Hunt5, Marissa Kinney2, Jahnavi Pathak1, Gary M. Mawe3,Peter L. Moses3,6, Emma Perry7, Allesandra Stratigakis8, Tao Zhang8, Grace Chen9, Suzanne L. Ishaq1*, Yanyan Li1*

1 Graduate School of Biomedical Sciences and Engineering, University of Maine, Orono, Maine, USA 04469. 2 School of Food and Agriculture, University of Maine, Orono, Maine, USA 04469. 3 Larner College of Medicine, University of Vermont, Burlington, Vermont, USA 05401. 4 Department of Biology, Husson University, Bangor, Maine, USA 04401. 5 Department of Biology, University of Maine, Orono, Maine, USA 04469. 6 Finch Therapeutics, Somerville, Massachusetts, USA 02143. 7 Electron Microscopy Laboratory, University of Maine, Orono, Maine, USA 04469. 8 School of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences, SUNY Binghamton University, Johnson City, New York, USA 13790. 9 Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA 48109

$ these authors contributed equally.

Keywords: Crohn’s Disease, cruciferous vegetables, sulforaphane, glucoraphanin, gut microbiota, dietary bioactives, 16S rDNA, interleukin-10 knockout 

Abstract

Crohn’s Disease (CD) is a presentation of Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) that manifests in childhood and adolescence, and involves chronic and severe enterocolitis, immune and gut microbial dysregulation, and other complications. Diet and gut-microbiota-produced metabolites are sources of anti-inflammatories which could ameliorate symptoms. However, questions remain on how IBD influences biogeographic patterns of microbial location and function in the gut, how early life transitional gut communities are affected by IBD and diet interventions, and how disruption to biogeography alters disease mediation by diet components or microbial metabolites. Many studies on diet and IBD use a chemically induced ulcerative colitis model, despite the availability of an immune-modulated CD model. Interleukin-10-knockout (IL-10-KO) mice on a C57BL/6 background, beginning at age 4 or 7 weeks, were fed a control diet or one containing 10% (w/w) raw broccoli sprouts, which was high in the sprout-sourced anti-inflammatory sulforaphane. Diets began 7 days prior to, and for 2 weeks after inoculation with Helicobacter hepaticus, which triggers Crohn’s-like symptoms in these immune-impaired mice. The broccoli sprout diet increased sulforaphane in plasma; decreased weight stagnation, fecal blood, and diarrhea associated; and increased microbiota richness in the gut, especially in younger mice. Sprout diets resulted in some anatomically specific bacteria in younger mice, and reduced the prevalence and abundance of pathobiont bacteria which trigger inflammation in the IL-10-KO mouse, e.g., Escherichia coli and Helicobacter. Overall, the IL-10-KO mouse model is responsive to a raw broccoli sprout diet and represents an opportunity for more diet-host-microbiome research.

Importance

To our knowledge, IL-10-KO mice have not previously been used to investigate the interactions of host, microbiota, and broccoli, broccoli sprouts, or broccoli bioactives in resolving symptoms of CD. We showed that a diet containing 10% raw broccoli sprouts increased the plasma concentration of the anti-inflammatory compound sulforaphane, and protected mice to varying degrees against disease symptoms, including weight loss or stagnation, fecal blood, and diarrhea. Younger mice responded more strongly to the diet, further reducing symptoms, as well as increased gut bacterial richness, increased bacterial community similarity to each other, and more location-specific communities than older mice on the diet intervention. Crohn’s Disease disrupts the lives of patients, and requires people to alter dietary and lifestyle habits to manage symptoms. The current medical treatment is expensive with significant side effects, and a dietary intervention represents an affordable, accessible, and simple strategy to reduce the burden of symptoms.

Acknowledgements: This project was supported by the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture through the Maine Agricultural & Forest Experiment Station: Hatch Project Numbers ME022102 and ME022329 (Ishaq) and ME022303 (Li); the USDA-NIFA-AFRI Foundational Program [Li and Chen; USDA/NIFA 2018-67017-27520/2018-67017-36797]; and the National Institute of Health [Li and Ishaq; NIH/NIDDK 1R15DK133826-01] which supported Marissa Kinney, Timothy Hunt, and Benjamin Hunt. Johanna Holman was supported by ME0-22303 (Li), and Lola Holcomb was supported by US National Science Foundation One Health and the Environment (OG&E): Convergence of Social and Biological Sciences NRT program grant DGE-1922560, and the UMaine Graduate School of Biomedical Science and Engineering.

Media/Interviews:

  1. ASM Press Release, Nov 9, 2023
  2. “Can broccoli sprouts be used to treat IBD? UMaine researchers investigate”, Carly D’Eon, News Center Maine, Nov 22, 2022.
  3. “UMaine researchers studying whether broccoli sprouts can help prevent and treat inflammatory bowel disease”, Marcus Wolf, UMaine News.

Steamed broccoli sprouts alleviate DSS-induced inflammation and retain gut microbial biogeography in mice.

“Steamed broccoli sprouts alleviate DSS-induced inflammation and retain gut microbial biogeography in mice” is a publication that is part of a larger Broccoli project, in which we are evaluating the use of broccoli sprouts in the diet to enlist gut microbes to produce anti-inflammatories. You can read about the whole project here, with links to other resources.

The Premise

A cartoon of a bacteria eating broccoli and pooping out sulforaphane
Designed by Johanna Holman
A diagram with two panels, and a cartoon mouse in the middle. The cartoon mouse is eating broccoli, and a cartoon of the digestive tract is overlaid on the mouse's abdomen. Lines emanating from the broccoli point to the left panel, and show the compound glucoraphanin being converted into sulforaphane by the myrosinase enzyme. Lines emanating from the colon of the mouse point to the panel on the right, showing the same biochemical conversion by gut microbes.

Broccoli sprouts are very high in a compound called glucoraphanin. When glucoraphanin comes in contact with the myrosinase enzyme, also found in the sprouts, it is transformed into a compound that acts an an anti-inflammatory in people!

If you eat raw sprouts, this conversion happens when you cut or chew the sprouts, and that anti-inflammatory will get absorbed in your stomach. If you steam or cook the sprouts, you can inactivate the enzyme and leave the glucoraphanin compound alone. Some of your gut microbes are able to use the compound, and produce the anti-inflammatory right in your gut! We are trying to understand how and when this works, so we can use it to reduce symptoms of Inflammatory Bowel Disease.

The Mouse work

In the winter of 2020-2021, we ran a 40-day study with 40 mice housed at UMaine. The mice were divided into 4 groups: “control” which ate the mouse chow, “control+DSS” which ate the mouse chow and had colitis induced by adding DSS (a salt laxative) to their drinking water, “broccoli” which ate the mouse chow with steamed broccoli sprouts mixed in, and “broccoli+DSS” which ate the mouse chow/steamed broccoli sprouts diet and had colitis induced by adding DSS (salt laxative) to their drinking water. This work was led by Johanna Holman, who was a master’s student at the time; Lousia Colicci, who was an undergrad at Husson University at the time and is applying to medical schools now; Dorein Baudewyns, who was an undergrad at Husson University at the time and is completing a graduate program in Psychology at UMaine; and Joe Balkan, who was completing his senior year of high school at the time and has since begin an undergrad degree in Biology at Tufts University where he is preparing for medical school.

Person in a research facility holding up their arm with a mouse on it. Person is wearing a hairnet, nitrile gloves, surgical mask, and a surgical gown. They are holding their left arm up to the camera to show off a mouse with dark brown fur sitting on their arm. In the background is a metal shelf with containers of research materials.
Johanna Holman, graduate researcher in the Ishaq Lab
Louisa Colucci. Young woman with dark hair tied in a bun is sitting in a kayak with her paddle raised. She is wearing a black top and a red life-vest over it, in a light blue, single-person kayak. The kayak is in the water, most likely a lake, with the forested shoreline in the background.
Louisa Colucci.
A person holding a mouse in a research facility. The person is wearing a hairnet, nitrile gloves, a surgical mask, and a surgical gown. The mouse with dark brown fur is sitting on the top of the person's hand. In the background, there are metal shelves with bins and containers of research supplies.
Dorien Baudewyns, undergraduate researcher at Husson University
Joe Balkan, performing culturing of bacteria at the anaerobic chamber. Joe is wearing a face mask, and is holding up a culture plate. There are stacks of petri dishes inside the chamber.
Joe Balkan, undergraduate researcher at Tufts University, performing culturing of bacteria at the anaerobic chamber.
Close-up image of a small, dark brown mouse perched on the arm of a graduate researcher. The person is wearing a face mask and surgical gown.

The mice were weighed regularly and fecal samples assessed for blood (signs of colitis). At the end of the study, the mice were euthanized so we could study the bacteria in parts of the intestines that we can’t access in humans. We used as few mice as possible, and got as much information from this study as possible, to do as much good as we can with their sacrifice.

The Health Benefits

As we’d hoped, the broccoli+DSS mice that were eating the broccoli sprouts that were given colitis did much better than the control+DSS group who ate mouse chow during their colitis. The broccoli+DSS mice were able to keep gaining weight as they grew, had better consistency of their stool, and had lower amounts of proteins and other metabolities in their blood which indicate inflammation (lower cytokines and lipocalin). Those graphs are shown in the paper.

The Gut Microbes

We found a lot of interesting things with the microbial communities that were living in different parts of the intestines, but the most exciting was that broccoli sprouts in the diet helped microbial communities stay alive in their original gut locations even during colitis! Certain microbes like to live in particular places in our intestines based on where different ingredients in our diet get processed, or the local environment (like how acidic the intestinal neighborhood is), and this is called biogeography.

In the graph below, our control group mice (eating chow) or the broccoli group (eating chow plus sprouts), we see that microbial communites in the small intestines clustered away from the microbial communities in the large intestines.

The DSS salt laxative, and ulcerative colitis, wreak havoc on gut microbes because they cause physical damage to the lining of the intestine, which where many microbes that can be useful to us live on or near. When we induced colitis in mice that were eating mouse chow (control+DSS group), the damage to the intestines caused a loss to some of the microbes living in different places. The remaining microbes that could survive these tough conditions were basically the same ones regardless of where we we looked in the intestines.

But, if mice had colitis and were eating broccoli sprouts (broccoli+DSS), the microbes were able to survive in their original locations and preserved biogeography! This is important because where microbes live in the gut may determine if the beneficial things they make can help resolve IBD symptoms in specific locations in the gut.

Image by Johanna Holman, graph from the paper.

The Spatial Location of GLR-digesting-genes

Bejamin and Timothy Hunt are undergraduates in Biology who have been working on bioinformatics in the Ishaq Lab since December 2022 after completing Sue’s DNA Sequencing Data Analysis Class. They joined the DSS project to provide in-depth analysis on some of the sequences which matched bacteria that are known to convert GLR into the anti-inflammatory SFN, as well as analyze data comparing numbers of genes known to be involved in the process.

A cartoon of the intestines with bacteria of interest in the jejunum, ceculm and colon,
Cropped figure from the paper, made by Benjamin and Timothy.
Benjamin Hunt

The study of the bioproduction of SFN and its mucosal and luminal activity benefited from the biogeographical analysis of this study. It was interesting to note the extreme dominance of a Bacteroides species in the broccoli treatments. B. thetaiotaomicron was indicated based on BLASTN analysis and an evaluation of matching species but was not directly suggested by the dada-Silva taxonomy assignment. The indication of B. thetaiotaomicron suggested analyzing the presence of the operon BT2159-BT2156, which was generally minimally present (<100) but at relatively high counts (>100,000) in some samples. Significantly, the operon was found at locations where no Bacteroides were identified. We continue to reflect on the similarities and differences in the biogeography of bacterial abundance and operon presence highlighted in the different treatments of this study.

Benjamin and Timothy Hunt

The Next Steps

As part of this project, we cultured hundreds of bacteria from the intestines of mice to try and isolate some of the ones that turn glucroraphanin into sulforaphane. We have a large team of students and researchers participating on the culturing work, some of whom are pictured here. We’ll be providing plenty of updates on that project as we continue to process the bacteria this fall!

  • Gallery Image
  • Gallery Image
  • Gallery Image
  • Gallery Image

The Paper

Steamed broccoli sprouts alleviate DSS-induced inflammation and retain gut microbial biogeography in mice.

Johanna M. Holman1, Louisa Colucci2, Dorien Baudewyns3, Joe Balkan4, Timothy Hunt5, Benjamin Hunt5, Marissa Kinney1, Lola Holcomb6, Allesandra Stratigakis7, Grace Chen8, Peter L. Moses9,10, Gary M. Mawe9, Tao Zhang7, Yanyan Li1*, Suzanne L. Ishaq1*

1 School of Food and Agriculture, University of Maine, Orono, Maine, USA 04469 2 Department of Biology, Husson University, Bangor, Maine, USA 04401 3 Department of Psychology, University of Maine, Orono, USA 04469 4 Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Tufts University, Medford, Massachusetts, USA 02155 5 Department of Biology, University of Maine, Orono, Maine, USA 04469 6 Graduate School of Biomedical Sciences and Engineering, University of Maine, Orono, Maine, USA 04469 7 School of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences, SUNY Binghamton University, Johnson City, New York, USA 13790 8Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA 48109 9Departments of Neurological Sciences and of Medicine, Larner College of Medicine, University of Vermont, Burlington, Vermont, USA 0540110 Finch Therapeutics, Somerville, Massachusetts, USA 02143

Abstract: Inflammatory Bowel Diseases (IBD) are devastating conditions of the gastrointestinal tract with limited treatments, and dietary intervention may be effective, and affordable, for managing symptoms. Glucosinolate compounds are highly concentrated in broccoli sprouts, especially glucoraphanin, and can be metabolized by certain mammalian gut bacteria into anti-inflammatory isothiocyanates, such as sulforaphane. Gut microbiota exhibit biogeographic patterns, but it is unknown if colitis alters these or whether the location of glucoraphanin-metabolizing bacteria affects anti-inflammatory benefits. We fed specific pathogen free C57BL/6 mice either a control diet or a 10% steamed broccoli sprout diet, and gave a three-cycle regimen of 2.5% dextran sodium sulfate (DSS) in drinking water over a 34-day experiment to simulate chronic, relapsing ulcerative colitis. We monitored body weight, fecal characteristics, lipocalin, serum cytokines, and bacterial communities from the luminal- and mucosa-associated populations in the jejunum, cecum, and colon. Mice fed the broccoli sprout diet with DSS treatment performed better than mice fed the control diet with DSS, including significantly more weight gain, lower Disease Activity Indexes, lower plasma lipocalin and proinflammatory cytokines, and higher bacterial richness in all gut locations. Bacterial communities were assorted by gut location, but were more homogenous across locations in the control diet + DSS mice. Importantly, our results showed that broccoli sprout feeding abrogated the effects of DSS on gut microbiota, as bacterial richness and biogeography were similar between mice receiving broccoli sprouts with and without DSS. Collectively, this supports the protective effect of steamed broccoli sprouts against dysbiosis and colitis induced by DSS.


Importance: Evaluating bacterial communities across different locations in the gut provides a greater insight than fecal samples alone, and provides an additional metric by which to evaluate beneficial host-microbe interactions. Here, we show that 10% steamed broccoli sprouts in the diet protects mice from the negative effects of dextran sodium sulfate induced colitis, that colitis erases biogeographical patterns of bacterial communities in the gut, and that the cecum is not likely to be a significant contributor to colonic bacteria of interest in the DSS mouse model of ulcerative colitis. Mice fed the broccoli sprout diet during colitis performed better than mice fed the control diet while receiving DSS. The identification of accessible dietary components and concentrations that help maintain and correct the gut microbiome may provide universal and equitable approaches to IBD prevention and recovery, and broccoli sprouts represent a promising strategy.

Acknowledgements: All authors have read and approved the final manuscript. The authors thank Jess Majors, University of Maine, for her kind and detailed care of the mice during the trial, and for Ellie Pelletier for her informal review of the manuscript. This project was supported by the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture through the Maine Agricultural & Forest Experiment Station: Hatch Project Numbers ME022102 and ME022329 (Ishaq) and ME022303 (Li) which supported Johanna Holman; the USDA-NIFA-AFRI Foundational Program [Li and Chen; USDA/NIFA 2018-67017-27520/2018-67017-36797]; and the National Institute of Health [Li and Ishaq; NIH/NIDDK 1R15DK133826-01] which supported Marissa Kinney, Timothy Hunt, and Benjamin Hunt. Lola Holcomb was supported by US National Science Foundation One Health and the Environment (OG&E): Convergence of Social and Biological Sciences NRT program grant DGE-1922560, and through the UMaine Graduate School of Biomedical Sciences and Engineering. 

Conference Presentations:

Holman-poster-ASN-2023Download
  1. Holman, J., Holcomb, L., Colucci, L. Baudewyns, D., Balkan, J., Chen. G., Moses, P.,  Mawe, G.M.,  Zhang, T., Li, Y., Ishaq, S.L. Steamed broccoli sprouts alleviate gut inflammation and retain gut microbiota against DSS-induced dysbiosis. American Society for Nutrition annual meeting, Boston, MA. July 22-25, 2023.
  2. Kinney, M., Holman, J., Hunt, T., Hunt, B., Zhang, T., Chen, G., Li , Y.,  Ishaq, S.L. Establishing Growth Curve Assays for Bacterial Glucosinolate Metabolism: A Study Protocol. American Society for Nutrition annual meeting, Boston, MA. July 22-25, 2023.
  3. Li, Y. “Broccoli Sprout Bioactives and Gut Microbiota: A Dietary Approach for Prevention and Management of Inflammatory Bowel Disease”. Microbes of Social Equity working group 2023 speaker series. Virtual. Jan 18, 2023. (invited).
  4. Holman, J. M., S. Ishaq, Y. Li, T. Zhang, G. Mawe, L. Colucci, J. Balkan. Prevention of Inflammatory Bowel Disease by Broccoli Sourced and Microbially Produced Bioactives.  American Society for Microbiology (ASM) Microbe 2022, Washington, DC (USA), June 12, 2022.
  5. Ishaq, S., Li, Y., Holman*2, J., Zhang, T., Chen, G. “Biogeography may be key to microbial anti inflammatory production using dietary precursors.” Maine Biological and Medical Sciences Symposium, Bar Harbor, ME, April 22-23, 2022. (invited)
  6. Ishaq*, S., Li, Y., Holman2, J., Zhang, T., Mawe, G., Hurd, M., Lavoie, B. Baudewyns1, D., Colucci1, L., Balkan1, J., Chen, G, Moses, P. “Biogeography may be key to microbial anti inflammatory production using dietary precursors.”  Congress of Gastrointestinal Function (CGIF), virtual. April 11 – 13, 2022.
    1. 46 students and faculty researchers
  7. Ishaq*, S., Li, Y., Holman2, J., Zhang, T., Mawe, G., Hurd, M., Lavoie, B. Baudewyns1, D., Colucci1, L., Balkan1, J., Chen, G, Moses, P. “Biogeography may be key to microbial anti inflammatory production using dietary precursors.”  Dartmouth Molecular Microbiology and Pathogenesis (M2P2), February 24 – 25, 2022. (invited)
    1. 120 students and faculty researchers.
  8. Holman2 J., Ishaq S.L.., Li Y., Zhang T., Balkan1 J., Colucci1 L. Prevention of inflammatory bowel disease by broccoli-sourced and microbially-produced bioactives. Video presented at: OHS Student Led Research Panel, UC Davis; Nov 2021.
  9. Holman*2, J., Ishaq, S.L., Li, Y., Zhang, T.. Prevention of Inflammatory Bowel Disease by Broccoli-sourced and Microbially-produced Bioactives. ASM Microbe/ISME World Microbe Forum 2021 (virtual). June 20-24, 2021. (poster)

Media/Interviews:

  1. “Can broccoli sprouts be used to treat IBD? UMaine researchers investigate”, Carly D’Eon, News Center Maine, Nov 22, 2022.
  2. “UMaine researchers studying whether broccoli sprouts can help prevent and treat inflammatory bowel disease”, Marcus Wolf, UMaine News.

Bacterial community trends associated with sea scallop, Placopecten magellanicus, larvae in a hatchery system.

Scallops are a diverse animal group of marine bivalve mollusks (family Pectinidae) with global distribution in coastal waters, and Atlantic deep-sea scallops, Placopecten magellanicus, are found along the eastern coast of the United States and Canada. Scallops’ reproductive potential and industry demand make them a prime target for hatchery- and farm-based production, and this has been successfully achieved in bay scallops, but not in sea scallops. Currently, hatcheries collect wild sea scallop adults, or maintain cultured broodstocks, and spawn them in their facilities with the intention of forming a plentiful population to grow to adulthood, spawn, and sell to create a sustainable production cycle while also reducing disruption to the scallops’ natural habitat.

Unfortunately, in sea scallop hatcheries the last two weeks of the larval maturation phase, the veliger-stage, is plagued by large mortality events, going from 60 million sea scallop larvae down to several thousand individuals in a span of 48 hours. Survival of clutches to maturity remains very low, with an industry-standard rate around 1%. This drastic winnowing of larvae reduces the availability of cultured sea scallop spat for farmers, forcing sea scallop farms to rely almost exclusively on sea scallop spat collected from wild populations for stock and is seen as a bottleneck for growth of the industry and achieving sustainable harvests. Hatchery larval die-off is well-demonstrated not to be caused by inadequate diet, lighting, temperature, or atmospheric pressure in aquaculture facilities compared to wild conditions.

This project wanted to know if there was any clue in the bacteria that associate with larvae, or with the tanks they are in. In particular, hactcheries are worried about certain species of bacteria in the genus Vibrio, as they can cause disease to scallops and/or people, but it is tricky to study them because there are many species which do nothing at all. This project is part of another experiment to examine some of the Vibrio we found in tanks.

We sampled from some wild larvae, hatchery larvae, and from tank biofilms to indentify what was there. There were two styles of tank setup, and we collected from used tanks as well as tanks after they had been cleaned and refilled with filtered seawater.

Veliger-stage Atlantic sea scallop larvae (Placopecten magellanicus) were obtained from hatchery tanks in Beals, Maine and from the wild off the coast of Cape Elizabeth, Maine. Swabs of hatchery tank biofilms were collected before and after tank cleaning. Bacterial communities were identified using DNA extraction and 16S rDNA sequencing on wild veligers, hatchery veligers and biofilm swabs. Image created with biorender.

One of the surprising things we found, was that the bacterial communities in biofilms along the sides of larvae tank were more similar to each other (clustering) when samples were collected during the same phase of the lunar cycle. Bacterial richness and community similarity between tank samples fluctuated over the trial in repeated patterns of rise and fall, which showed some correlation to lunar cycle  where richness is high when the moon is about 50% and richness is low during new and full moon phases. This may be a proxy for the effects of spring tides and trends in seawater bacteria and phages which are propagated into hatchery tanks. The number of days since the full moon was significantly correlated with bacterial community richness in tanks: low during the full moon, peaking ~ 21 days after the full moon, and decreasing again at the next full moon.  

Fig. 7. Constrained ordination of bacterial communities in tank samples. Each point represents the bacterial community from one sample. Similarity between samples was calculated using Distance-based Redundancy Analysis (dbDRA), and significant model factors (anova, p < 0.01) are displayed with arrow lengths relative to their importance in the model (f value). The shape of points indicates whether swabbing was either immediately after filtered seawater has been used to fill the tank (cleaned, refilled) or 48 hours after (dirty, drained). Tank setup indicates if water was static, constantly filtered and recirculated in a flow-through system, or setup information was not available (n/a).

These results along with future work, will inform hatcheries on methods that will increase larval survival in these facilities, for example, implementing additional filtering or avoiding seawater collection during spring tides, to reduce certain bacterial taxa of concern or promoting a more diverse microbial community which would compete against pathogens.

Bacterial community trends associated with sea scallop, Placopecten magellanicus, larvae in a hatchery system.

Authors: Suzanne L. Ishaq1*, Sarah Hosler1, Adwoa Dankwa1, Phoebe Jekielek2, Damian C. Brady3, Erin Grey4,5, Hannah Haskell6, Rachel Lasley-Rasher6, Kyle Pepperman7, Jennifer Perry1, Brian Beal8, Timothy J. Bowden1

Affiliations:1 School of Food & Agriculture, University of Maine, Orono ME 044692 Ecology and Environmental Sciences, University of Maine, Orono ME 044733 School of Marine Sciences, Darling Marine Center, University of Maine, Walpole ME 045734 School of Biology and Ecology, University of Maine, Orono ME 044695 Maine Center for Genetics in the Environment, University of Maine, Orono ME 044696 Department of Biological Sciences, University of Southern Maine, Portland ME 041037 Downeast Institute, Beals, ME 046118 Division of Environmental & Biological Sciences, University of Maine at Machias, Machias, ME 04654

Abstract

Atlantic sea scallops, Placopecten magellanicus, are the most economically important marine bivalves along the northeastern coast of North America. Wild harvest landings generate hundreds of millions of dollars, and wild-caught adults and juvenile spat are increasingly being cultured in aquaculture facilities and coastal farms. However, the last two weeks of the larval maturation phase in hatcheries are often plagued by large mortality events. Research into other scallop- and aquacultured-species point to bacterial infections or altered functionality of microbial communities which associate with the host. Despite intense filtering and sterilization of seawater, and changing tank water every 48 hours, harmful microbes can still persist in biofilms and mortality is still high. There are no previous studies of the bacterial communities associated with the biofilms growing in scallop hatchery tanks, nor studies with wild or hatchery sea scallops. We characterized the bacterial communities in veliger-stage wild or hatchery larvae, and tank biofilms using the 16S rDNA gene V3-V4 region sequenced on the Illumina MiSeq platform. Hatchery larvae had lower bacterial richness (number of bacteria taxa present) than the wild larvae and tank biofilms, and hatchery larvae had a similar bacterial community (which taxa were present) to both wild larvae and tank biofilms. Bacterial richness and community similarity between tank samples fluctuated over the trial in repeated patterns of rise and fall, which showed some correlation to lunar cycle that may be a proxy for the effects of spring tides and trends in seawater bacteria and phages which are propagated into hatchery tanks. These results along with future work, will inform hatcheries on methods that will increase larval survival in these facilities, for example, implementing additional filtering or avoiding seawater collection during spring tides, to reduce bacterial taxa of concern or promote a more diverse microbial community which would compete against pathogens.

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank the staff at the Downeast Institute for supporting the development and implementation of this project, as well as for financially supporting the DNA sequencing; Meredith White of Mook Sea Farm for sharing her expertise and collecting biofilm samples; the Darling Marine Center for sharing their expertise and collecting biofilm samples; and the Sea Scallop Hatchery Implementation (Hit) Team for their expertise, review of this work, and funding support, who are financially supported by the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission and Michael & Alison Bonney. The authors thank Lilian Nowak for assistance with related lab work to this project, and the Map Top Scholars Program for related financial support. The authors also thank Nate Perry for helping us collect wild scallop larvae. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript. This project was supported by the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture through the Maine Agricultural & Forest Experiment Station, Hatch Project Numbers: ME0-22102 (Ishaq), ME0-22309 (Bowden), and ME0-21915 (Perry); as well through NSF #OIA-1849227 to Maine EPSCoR at the University of Maine (Grey). This project was supported by an Integrated Research and Extension Grant from the Maine Food and Agriculture Center, with funding from the Maine Economic Improvement Fund.

Ishaq, S.L., Hosler2, S., Dankwa, A., Jekielek, P., Brady, D.C., Grey, E., Haskell, H., Lasley-Rasher, R., Pepperman, K., Perry, J., Beal, B., Bowden, T.J. 2023. Bacterial community trends associated with sea scallop, Placopecten magellanicus, larvae in a hatchery system. Aquaculture Reports 32: 101693.

Warmer water temperature and epizootic shell disease reduces diversity but increases cultivability of bacteria on the shells of American Lobster (Homarus americanus).

This collaborative paper investigates what happens to bacterial communities on healthy and sick lobsters as they experience different water temperatures for a year: “Water temperature and disease alters bacterial diversity and cultivability from American Lobster (Homarus americanus) shells.”

Woman sitting outside.

I joined this project back in the summer of 2020, towards the end of my first year at UMaine, when I was given a large 16S rRNA gene sequence dataset of bacterial communities from the shells of lobsters. I had been asking around for data as a training opportunity for Grace Lee, who at the time was an undergraduate at Bowdoin College participating in the abruptly cancelled summer Research Experience for Undergrads program at UMaine in summer 2020. Instead, Grace joined my lab as a remote research assistant and we worked through the data analysis over the summer and fall. Grace has since graduated with her Bachelor’s of Science in Neuroscience, obtained a Master’s of Science at Bowdoin, and is currently a researcher at Boston Children’s Hospital while she is applying to medical school.

My first point of contact on the project was Jean MacRae, an Associate Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering at UMaine, who was the one to lend me the data and who had been working on bacterial community sequencing on other projects which I’ve been involved in. Jean has been involved with MSE, and this is our fourth publication together making her the collaborator at UMaine I have co-authored with the most (although it is a tight race 🙂 ).

Four professors wearing full regalia, as well as face masks, posing for a photo in a hallway.

Jean introduced me to the original research team, including Debbie Bouchard, who is the Director of the Aquaculture Research Institute and was researching epizootic shell disease in lobsters for her PhD dissertation several years ago; Heather Hamlin, Professor and Director of the School of Marine Sciences; Scarlett Tudor (not pictured), the Education and Outreach Coordinator at the ARI; and Sarah Turner (not pictured), Scientific Research Specialist at ARI. The ARI team is involved in a lot of large-scale aquaculture research, education, and outreach to the industry here in Maine, and the collaborative work I have been doing with them has been a new an engaging avenue of scientific study for me.

In 2022, the research team, along with social science Masters student Joelle Kilchenmann, published a perspective/hypothesis piece which explored unanswered questions about how the movement of microbes, lobsters, and climate could affect the spread of epizootic shell disease in lobsters off the coast of Maine. That perspective paper was a fun exercise in hypothesis generation and asking ‘what if‘?

A steamed lobster on a plate.

This paper is more grounded, and features work that was started in 2016. It examines bacterial communities on the shells of lobsters which were captured off the coast of Southern Maine and maintained in aquarium tanks for over a year. The lobsters were split into three treatment groups: those which were kept in water temperatures that mimicked what they would experience in Southern Maine, colder water to simulated what they would experience in Northern Maine, and hotter water to simulate what they would experience in Southern New England over that year. The original project team wanted to know if temperatures would make a different to their health or microbial communities.

Figure S8. Water temperature regimes, related to STAR Methods. A. Temperatures were obtained through the National Oceanographic Data Center (NODC). NODC temperatures reflect those recorded near Eastport, ME (A); Portland, ME (B); and an average of temperatures from Woods Hole, MA (C) and New Haven, CT (D) was used to represent Southern New England. B. Annual temperature cycles used in this project to represent Southern New England (SNE), Southern Maine (SME) and Northern Maine (NME).

The original project team swabbed lobster shells to obtain bacteria to try and grow in the lab, as well as DNA to sequence and identify whole bacterial communities. Grace and I performed the data analysis to identify which taxa were present in those communities, what happened over time or when the water temperature changed, and what bacteria were present or not in lobsters which died during the study.

Figure S11. Lobster carapace sampling using a sterile cotton swab to obtain bacterial communities from the shell surface, related to STAR Methods. The right side of the dorsolateral area of the cephalothorax was sampled for the baseline sampling, the left side for the Time 1, and the right side again for Time 2.

In addition to wanting to know about temperature, we wanted to know specifically how temperature would affect the bacteria if the lobsters had epizootic shell disease. It is not known what causes epizootic shell disease (which is why it is called ‘epizootic’), but it manifests as pitting in the shells of lobsters. Over time, the pitting can weaken shells and make it difficult for the lobster to molt, or make the lobster susceptible to predators or microbial infections. This type of shell disease had been a huge problem in Southern New England over the past few decades, and in Maine we have seen more cases over time.

Four panels of lobsters showing the progression of a healthy lobster to ones with more and more pitting in their shells.
Figure S10. Examples of lobster shell disease indices, related to STAR Methods. A) 0, no observable signs of disease, B) 1+, shell disease signs on 1-10% of the shell surface, C) 2+, shell disease signs on 11-50% of the shell surface, D) 3+, shell disease signs on > 50% of the shell surface.

The highlights of this project are here, but you can click the link below to read the entire study and what happened to lobster health and lobster microbes over time.

  • Shell bacteria from healthy lobsters, often overlooked, were included in the study.
  • Hotter and colder water temperatures affected shell bacterial communities.
  • Epizootic shell disease reduced bacterial diversity on lobster shells.
  • Epizootic shell disease could be induced or exacerbated by the loss of commensal bacteria from shells.

“Water temperature and disease alters bacterial diversity and cultivability from American Lobster (Homarus americanus) shells.”

Suzanne L. Ishaq1,2,, Sarah M. Turner2,3, Grace Lee4,5,M. Scarlett Tudor2,3, Jean D. MacRae6, Heather Hamlin2,7, Deborah Bouchard2,3

  • 1 School of Food and Agriculture; University of Maine; Orono, Maine, 04469; USA.
  • 2 Aquaculture Research Institute; University of Maine; Orono, Maine, 04469; USA.
  • 3 Cooperative Extension; University of Maine; Orono, Maine, 04469; USA.
  • 4 Department of Neuroscience, Bowdoin College, Brunswick, ME 04011; USA.
  • 5 Boston Children’s Hospital, Boston, MA 02115; USA.
  • 6 Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering; University of Maine; Orono, Maine, 04469; USA.
  • 7 School of Marine Sciences; University of Maine; Orono, Maine, 04469; USA.

iScience 26(5): 106606.

Summary

The American lobster, Homarus americanus, is an economically valuable and ecologically important crustacean along the North Atlantic coast of North America. Populations in southern locations have declined in recent decades due to increasing ocean temperatures and disease, and these circumstances are progressing northward. We monitored 57 adult female lobsters, healthy and shell-diseased, under three seasonal temperature cycles for a year, to track shell bacterial communities using culturing and 16S rRNA gene sequencing, progression of ESD using visual assessment, and antimicrobial activity of hemolymph. The richness of bacterial taxa present, evenness of abundance, and community similarity between lobsters was affected by water temperature at the time of sampling, water temperature over time based on seasonal temperature regimes, shell disease severity, and molt stage. Several bacteria were prevalent on healthy lobster shells but missing or less abundant on diseased shells, although some bacteria were found on all shells regardless of health status.

A diagram with two panels, and a cartoon mouse in the middle. The cartoon mouse is eating broccoli, and a cartoon of the digestive tract is overlaid on the mouse's abdomen. Lines emanating from the broccoli point to the left panel, and show the compound glucoraphanin being converted into sulforaphane by the myrosinase enzyme. Lines emanating from the colon of the mouse point to the panel on the right, showing the same biochemical conversion by gut microbes.

Interplay of broccoli/broccoli sprout bioactives with gut microbiota in reducing inflammation in inflammatory bowel diseases

As part of her master’s of science thesis in 2022, Johanna Holman reviewed hundreds of journal articles on anti-inflammatory, health-promoting dietary compounds in broccoli and other vegetables or fruits, and how microbes in the digestive tract can transform inactive precursors from foods into those beneficial compounds.

A cartoon of three gastrointestinal tracts showing the locations of inflammation in ulcerative colitis, crohn's disease, or healthy tissue. At the bottom are cross-sections showing thickening of the intestinal wall in patients with Crohn's, and ulcers in patients with colitis.
Figure 1. Primary Inflammatory Bowel Disease presentations, ulcerative colitis (UC) and Crohn’s disease (CD), compared to a healthy colon. UC is limited to the colon and is characterized by pseudopolyps and haustra loss (smoothing and shortening of the colon). CD can occur anywhere in the GI tract and is characterized by fissures, muscle thickening, and “cobblestoning”, which is the unique bubbling of the interior wall.

This is part of a broader research collaboration on how glucoraphanin in broccoli sprouts can be made into sulforaphane, which acts as an anti-inflammatory in humans (work that has been funded by the Allen Foundation). Humans are unable to convert glucoraphanin to sulforaphane, and a small amount of this occurs naturally thanks to enzymes in the broccoli sprouts. But, certain gut microbes can make the conversion and this has helped resolve colitis and other symptoms in mice in laboratory trials (manuscripts in review, work that has been funded by the NIH).

A diagram with two panels, and a cartoon mouse in the middle. The cartoon mouse is eating broccoli, and a cartoon of the digestive tract is overlaid on the mouse's abdomen. Lines emanating from the broccoli point to the left panel, and show the compound glucoraphanin being converted into sulforaphane by the myrosinase enzyme. Lines emanating from the colon of the mouse point to the panel on the right, showing the same biochemical conversion by gut microbes.
Figure 2. (A) Glucoraphanin hydrolysis in the presence of plant myrosinase upon damage to the broccoli plant. Epithiospecifier protein preferentially converts glucoraphanin to sulforaphane-nitrile. (B) Glucoraphanin hydrolysis has been demonstrated by gut bacteria in the cecum and colon of mammals. Low pH environments favor conversion to sulforaphane-nitrile.

Interplay of Broccoli/Broccoli Sprout Bioactives with Gut Microbiota in Reducing Inflammation in Inflammatory Bowel Diseases.

Holman, J., Hurd, M., Moses, P.,  Mawe, G.,  Zhang, T., Ishaq, S.L., Li, Y. 2022. The Journal of Nutritional Biochemistry 113: 109238.

Abstract

Inflammatory Bowel Diseases (IBD) are chronic, reoccurring, and debilitating conditions characterized by inflammation in the gastrointestinal tract, some of which can lead to more systemic complications and can include autoimmune dysfunction, a change in the taxonomic and functional structure of microbial communities in the gut, and complicated burdens in a person’s daily life. Like many diseases based in chronic inflammation, research on IBD has pointed towards a multifactorial origin involving factors of the person’s lifestyle, immune system, associated microbial communities, and environmental conditions. Treatment currently exists only as palliative care, and seeks to disrupt the feedback loop of symptoms by reducing inflammation and allowing as much of a return to homeostasis as possible. Various anti-inflammatory options have been explored, and this review focuses on the use of diet as an alternative means of improving gut health. Specifically, we highlight the connection between the role of sulforaphane from cruciferous vegetables in regulating inflammation and in modifying microbial communities, and to break down the role they play in IBD.

Acknowledgements: The authors would like to thank Brigitte Lavoie (University of Vermont) and Grace Chen (University of Michigan), as well as undergraduate researchers Dorien Baudewyns (Husson University), Louisa Colucci (Husson University), and Joe Balkan (Tufts University), for their work on the laboratory research which forms the broader collaboration that led to the generation of this review. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript. This project was supported by the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture, Hatch Project Numbers ME0-22102 (Ishaq) and ME0-22303 (Li) through the Maine Agricultural & Forest Experiment Station, and USDA-NIFA-AFRI Foundational Program [Grant No. 2018-67017-27520]. It was also supported by NIH grant NOA R21AT011203 (Mawe).

Conflict of Interest: The authors declare no conflicts of interest.